This story was originally published by HuffPost Canada.
Two First Nations chiefs who signed letters of support for the Trans Mountain pipeline expansion say they don’t truly support the project.
Chief Robert Joseph of Ditidaht First Nation told the Tracking Trans Mountain team that he felt fighting the pipeline was futile.
“At the end of the day, we are not really in favour of any pipeline, but we believe it’s going to go through anyway,” Joseph said. “They will not listen to anybody and that’s the history of consultation with First Nations people … They consult and go ahead and do what they were going to do anyways.”
Canada’s federal government is buying the existing pipeline and materials for the expansion project from Kinder Morgan for $4.5 billion.
Finance Minister Bill Morneau explains the decision to buy Trans Mountain. Via Bill Morneau/Facebook
The 43 mutual benefit agreements that Kinder Morgan says it has signed with Indigenous groups in B.C. and Alberta will be honoured after the sale, a Finance Department spokesperson told HuffPost Canada in an email.
An unnamed federal government source told The Canadian Press on Tuesday that more Indigenous groups support the project than oppose it. But some groups that did sign agreements say there was no other choice.
Consultation process not meaningful: chief
Ditidaht is a nation of 774 members with 17 reserves. Its main community is located on the west coast of Vancouver Island. About six kilometres of the shipping route for Trans Mountain tankers falls within traditional territory claimed by Ditidaht in submissions for the B.C. Treaty process.
Ditidaht has expressed many concerns about the project, according to a document prepared by the Environmental Assessment Office, including:
Planning for an oil spill has been inadequate, especially in regards to extreme weather and possible collisions between Ditidaht fishing boats and Trans Mountain tankers
Increases in marine traffic and pollution could cause a decline in fish populations
Ditidaht will assume a disproportionate amount of risk in the event of an oil spill or tanker accident
The National Energy Board downplayed the project’s effects on Ditidaht in its assessment of the project.
Joseph said he worried that if his nation opposed the project, they would be on their own if oil spills.
He said the consultation process wasn’t meaningful.
“Even if it’s the best consultation on the face of the earth, if they do what they were going to do anyhow, what’s the point?”
“… the most exhaustive review of any pipeline in Canadian history.”
– Alexandre Deslongchamps, Natural Resources spokesman
A spokesman for Minister of Natural Resources Jim Carr said this project was subject to “the most exhaustive review of any pipeline in Canadian history.”
Extensive consultation with Indigenous people was a key pillar of the government’s approach to Trans Mountain, Alexandre Deslongchamps told HuffPost Canada in an email.
“Through our review of the Trans Mountain Expansion, we added additional time and steps to the review process to make it more rigorous,” he said. “We extended consultation to ensure we were meeting and exceeding our duty to consult Indigenous peoples.”
Yale First Nation Chief Ken Hansen told APTN News that he wouldn’t have signed the agreement if his band had any other financial options.
“When I signed this deal, I felt a lot of shame,” he said.
Yale is located on the Fraser River, about 20 kilometres north of Hope, B.C. The nation has 172 members and 16 reserves. The proposed right-of-way runs about one kilometre away from a Yale reserve, through the nation’s asserted traditional territory.
“When I signed this deal, I felt a lot of shame.” – Ken Hansen
When Hansen was elected chief three years ago, his nation was broke. Yale was on the brink of third-party management, a system in which Ottawa places the finances of a nation under the control of an outside trustee.
So Hansen said he had to choose between accepting a deal with Kinder Morgan and implementing a treaty negotiated by Yale’s previous council with Canada and B.C., which would have relinquished the nation’s rights and title to its land.
“I literally had my hands tied … I was in a financial place where I had to accept [the Kinder Morgan] money,” he said. The money from Kinder Morgan has helped him build new housing and hire trained professionals to start the nation’s climb out of debt.
“I’m about the people,” he said. “Our people needed help and this is one way of getting it.”